More below the fold...
Also I
And just because it dovetail's quite nicely with this particular issue, here's another case-in-point, posted to further elucidate to students on the nature of hidden memory phenomenon - scientifically termed as "cryptomnesia." One of the feature gag cartoonists whose work I admire greatly, and spotlight in my comics course during the single-panel sessions, is Dave Coverly's "Speed Bump." This is one of the pieces that is in my slide-show which I've seen for so many years now I probably don't really pay much attention to them anymore:
This is perfect example of how one of the images I show to students during the related lecture became lodged in the brain, resurfacing many years later to manifest itself in a panel of my own, as seen below. In my opinion it's too close for comfort, like the "Eye Rolling" example above, and merited yanking from the pipeline. I think it's instructional to highlight these rare instances as it underscores the question if anything's truly original (I have been pecking away at another essay on that concept), and to what degree copyright inhibits along with ensuring protection of intellectual property. Now it's entirely a matter up for debate as to whether or not this example would constitute copying per say, and it probably doesn't quite rank as plagiarism, but it's Exhibit A in subconscious appropriation - or is it instead just inspiration? Either way it doesn't matter enough to stress over: just turn the page and simply draw another one, or a different take.
Checked the Interwebs for Gadsden Flag satire before drawing 3 or 4 panels I thought would be funny. That pared the list down to one or two...maybe. I do image searches all the time before getting too jacked about an idea. Don't know if it's a god thing or a bad thing, but since a lot of my joke ideas tend to be pretty obvious, I save myself a lot of trouble and disappointment by finding out at the outset that others have done it sooner and better.
ReplyDeleteThe sole redeeming factor in "someone else has already done it" is at least the fact that nobody's ever drawn YOURS: since you drew it it's original to you (subject to the same personal comfort level on the aesthetic/moral continuum from blissful ignorance to "ideas aren't copywritable" to the extreme of outright plagiarism).
DeleteStandup comedy is another analogous industry where it is frowned upon to lift material, even if one's delivery or routine is better. What with the current climate of massive lawsuits over simple beats & rhythms between dueling corporate vs legacy music rights it's inevitable other creative mediums will follow suit in such territorial pissings.
Your stuff is always more creative than that.
ReplyDeleteThanks... appreciate it. Now back to drawing a cartoon about a polar bear lost in a snowstorm, which I'm utterly convinced is a uniquely original concept.
ReplyDelete